Reform savings, a project that falls ill for banks
French banks fear that the project of President Francois Hollande to reform regulated savings in France deny them a windfall of cheap liquidity, while debt crisis in the euro area again threatens the ability of banks to refinance themselves on the European markets.
The new head of state, who voted in favor of a pact to support growth of the Agreement on budgetary discipline approved by 25 of the 27 countries of the European Union, wants to mobilize savings of the French to strengthen financial leeway of the state for housing and corporate finance.
His presidential program provided including a doubling of the ceiling of Booklet A and Booklet Sustainable Development (LDD), currently limited to 15,300 euros respectively and 6,000 euros. They are currently paid at a rate of 2.25%.
Francois Hollande hopes to encourage the creation of new social housing and transform the LDD in "savings book industry" dedicated to SME financing and business innovation.
If investors can not appreciate these reforms, credit institutions such as BNP Paribas and Societe Generale may see whole areas of savings leave their record to head the Caisse des Depots (CDC) that centralizes regulated savings in France.
According to Pascal Decque, an analyst at Cheuvreux, some 83 billion euros of savings could then migrate to the CDC.
Such a transfer would be another blow to banks
French who have already lost 90 billion euros of deposits last year due to concerns of investors about banks' exposure to Greece and the financial crisis.
"You have liquidity pressures in all sectors for French banks," said Andrew Lim, an analyst at Espirito Santo. The program of Francois Hollande "will put pressure on the deposit market."
Societe Generale has declined to comment on the subject while at BNP Paribas messages left unanswered.
NON-DISCLOSURE OF BANKERS
This regulated savings, which comes mainly from the Booklet A, is collected by the banking networks and centralized at the CDC in exchange for a commission paid to banks. The funds raised finance housing projects, infrastructure and other public projects.
According to statistics from the CDC, the outstanding book A and the LDD reached 295.1 billion euros at end-March.
Leaders of French banks, already reluctant to the idea of a banking reform that would isolate the activities according to their usefulness or not the economy, principal concern is that beyond the housing market deposits and the financing of major projects is entrusted to a public bank.
"Liquidity is our raw material, (Reform Booklet A, Ed) does not help us," said May 10 Perol President BPCE (People's Bank, Savings Bank), parent company of Natixis, radio BFM Business. "It's weird to send money to the Deposit which has no bank branch when there are French banks have 40,000 branches."
"French banks (…) have employees willing to work and to make loans to businesses that need," he added.
The CDC is well mobilized, through its infrastructure fund and Axa Private Equity and Vinci, to fund future high-speed line (HSL) between Tours and Bordeaux, an investment of more than seven billion euros.
"Is it necessary to finance SMEs by the CDC and insurers?" Plague a Parisian banker who requested anonymity. "With Francois Hollande, there is the return to France with the idea that the state does better. This is an old French fantasy. "
Reform of regulated savings" will destabilize the banks, "he says
. While many observers believe that with the new Basel III prudential banks can no longer finance long-term projects, some believe, however, that the state will not only fulfill these investments
. "The challenges of financing long-term investments can not be met if we depend only of a public actor, "says Gerard de la Martiniere, former president of the Federation of French society ; s insurance (FFSA)
.