Eight European banks have failed the stress test that would evaluate their response in the event of a prolonged recession, said Friday the EBA.
These reviews, which did not take into account the hypothesis of a defect in Greece, were conducted on 90 banks and forced the banks to deliver their anticipated results, to include depreciation in their bond assets and a subsequent rise their funding costs.
They found that banks that failed were in need of 2.5 billion euros in fresh capital, much less than anticipated by most analysts.
Five Spanish banks, two Greek and one Austrian were unable to overcome the hardest scenario.The markets were expecting 5 to 15 banks fail and they need to agree on 10 billion euros.
In the wake of the publication of these results, following the closure of European markets, the euro hit a session high against the dollar while Treasuries erased losses and went up.
"With only eight banks that fail, and the need for these banks to raise 2.5 billion euros of capital, it is not the solution if we are to restore confidence," said Michael Symonds, credit analyst Daiwa Capital Markets in London.
"What we needed was to see more banks fail and have to eventually raise more capital."
"That said, I do not think people really expected such a result.But the remedy for the broader malaise sovereign debt / bank in Europe must do more than simply injecting new capital into banks of Europe. "
To pass these tests, banks had to overcome an adverse scenario and come out with a hard capital ratio above 5.0%.The scenario in question provided a collapse of equity markets, bonds and real estate during a recession of two years.
In addition to eight banks that have failed these tests, 16 have succeeded only just.
"The European Banking Authority also recommended that national regulatory authorities that all banks whose capital ratios are above but close to 5% and have significant exposure to government bonds, making the decisions necessary to that 'they reinforce their positions, "said the EBA.
FAILURE NOT GREEK simulated live
The banks that failed now have until September to detail how they intend to close their deficit in equity, while their governments must be prepared to intervene with public funds if needed.
"The results of stress tests show that European banks are stronger and better able to withstand shocks," responded the European Commissioners for Internal Market and Economic and Monetary Affairs Michel Barnier and Olli Rehn in a joint statement.
The operation is not without detractors.These emphasize the absence of the hypothesis of a failure, even partial, of Greece, resulting in heavy losses for the French and German banks.
The BEA did not impose on banks a discount on long-term sovereign debt they hold, but asked them to consider the impact on their holdings of a lowering of the sovereign rating four notches, which reflect the failure of a country already rated poorly, such as Greece.
Under the plan, banks would suffer a 15% discount on the Greek paper they hold.Most experts believe, however, that market is expected that these shares lose 50% of their value.
FLIGHT OF SPREADS
The fear that the Greek crisis spread to Spain and Italy did fly the rate of return on the debt of these two countries and their banks.
Fearing that European banks are not strong enough to cope with such a contagion, the markets have driven down to the lowest in two years.
This series of tests is the third-and most rigorously conducted in European Union since the global financial crisis opened four years ago.
Tests conducted last year had presented the Irish banks as strong, just before they collapse and do not force Dublin to nationalize while demanding a European aid.
Several banks failed tests had already started the sale of assets to strengthen their capital base.
The Austrian Volksbanken Thursday had sold its subsidiary in Eastern Europe, VBI, in the Russian Sberbank.
The same day, the Greek EFG Eurobank announced to be in talks to sell a majority stake in its Turkish subsidiary Eurobank Tefken.
Initially 91 European banks should be subject to testing, but the German bank Helaba was ultimately not taken part in the exercise.